Topic: PhilPaprs Srvy Perception

Camp: Agreement / Disjunctivism

Camp Statement
Go live Time :


  • Lean Toward: Disjunctivism: 259 / 3226 (8%)
  • Accept: Disjunctivism: 99 / 3226 (3%)
  • Total: 358 / 3226 (11%)
Denies the 'common kind assumption' - that the perception is the same as the hallucination.
A subset of, or at least related to 'naive realism'

In Chalmers' 2004 paper "Perception and the Fall from Eden" (In (T. Gendler & J. Hawthorne, eds) Perceptual Experience. Oxford University Press, 2006.) he has a note on page 6 that describes his ideas about various kinds of disjunctivism most of which he is "inclined to reject":
  • Disjunctivism About Phenomenology: "Denies that experiences directed at different objects could have the same phenomenology, and denies that a hallucinatory experience could have the same phenomenology as an experience of an external object."
  • Disjunctivism About Metaphysics: "A hallucinatory experience and an ordinary perceptual experience may share phenomenal character, but holds that they have a fundamentally distinct underlying metaphysical nature: one experience involves an object and one does not."
  • Disjunctivism About Content: "These experiences have the same phenomenology, but holds that they have different representational contents: for example, experiences of different objects will have different object-involving contents." There are two sub types:
    • Denies that there is any phenomenal content, holding that the relevant experiences share no content
    • May accept that there is phenomenal content while holding that it is less fundamental than object-involving content

Support Tree for "Disjunctivism" Camp

Total Support for This Camp (including sub-camps):

Current Topic Record

Topic Name : PhilPaprs Srvy Perception
Namespace : /General/

Current Camp Record

Camp Name : Disjunctivism
Keywords : Disjunctivism
Camp About URL :
Camp About Nick Name : No nickname associated