Topic: Software = Qualia?

Camp: Agreement / No

Camp Statement History

Objected
Live
In Review
Old
Statement : We believe the idea that software can reproduce consciousness, or more specifically, any type of qualia, to be an obviously absurd and mistaken idea.
Computers represent information as numbers, in a binary format. One arbitrary pattern of ones and zeros could represent green while a different pattern could represent red. This representation is abstract and very different from qualia. Though a program can be written to differentiate one colour from another, this is purely automatic with not a scintilla of consciousness.
Our brain, on the other hand, has a radically different structure which does produce conscious experience. What we represent 700nm (red) and 500nm (green) light with, and what such representations are fundamentally like and how they are phenomenally different is the most important and fundamental attribute of what it means to be consciously aware, to perceive colour.
Computer software embedded in a robot can distinguish patterns of input from sensors and produce appropriate movements of actuators, but it is a mistake to see the behaviour and reason that the robot is conscious.

Edit summary : Focussing more on the topic
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : richwil
Go live Time :
Statement : We believe the idea that software can reproduce consciousness, or more specifically, any type of qualia, to be an obviously absurd and mistaken idea.
Today's abstract computers are specifically designed in such a way that it doesn't matter what the information, or the ones (could represent red) and zeros (could represent green), are represented by. That is why software is considered to be 'abstract'.
Our brain, on the other hand, is of an entirely different design. What we represent 700nm (red) and 500nm (green) light with, and what such representations are fundamentally like and how they are phenomenally different is the most important and fundamental attribute of what it means to be consciously aware.
Phenomenal red and green can abstractly represent things like 700nm and 500nm light (what our brain does do), and abstract things or software can fully represent, model, compute and behave just like qulia. But, just because most matter can be configured and / or interpreted to behave like something else doesn't mean it is fundamentally or phenomenally anything like the original.

Edit summary : add: Just because matter can be interpreted as...
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : Brent_Allsop
Go live Time :
Statement : We believe the idea that software can reproduce consciousness, or more specifically, any type of qualia, to be an obviously absurd and mistaken idea.
Today's abstract computers are specifically designed in such a way that it doesn't matter what the information, or the ones (could represent red) and zeros (could represent green), are represented by. That is why software is considered to be 'abstract'.
Our brain, on the other hand, is of an entirely different design. What we represent 700nm (red) and 500nm (green) light with, and what such representations are fundamentally like and how they are phenomenally different is the most important and fundamental attribute of what it means to be consciously aware.
Phenomenal red and green can abstractly represent things like 700nm and 500nm light (what our brain does do), and abstract things or software can fully represent, model, compute and behave just like qulia. But, just because something is fully representing or behaving like, doesn't mean it is fundamentally or phenomenally anything like the original.

Edit summary : Fix typo (computer -> compute)
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : Brent_Allsop
Go live Time :
Statement :
We believe the idea that software can reproduce consciousness, or more specifically, any type of qualia, to be an obviously absurd and mistaken idea.
Today's abstract computers are specifically designed in such a way that it doesn't matter what the information, or the ones (could represent red) and zeros (could represent green), are represented by. That is why software is considered to be 'abstract'.
Our brain, on the other hand, is of an entirely different design. What we represent 700nm (red) and 500nm (green) light with, and what such representations are fundamentally like and how they are phenomenally different is the most important and fundamental attribute of what it means to be consciously aware.
Phenomenal red and green can abstractly represent things like 700nm and 500nm light (what our brain does do), and abstract things or software can fully represent, model, computer and behave just like qulia. But, just because something is fully representing or behaving like, doesn't mean it is fundamentally or phenomenally anything like the original.

Edit summary : First Version after recycle.
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : Brent_Allsop
Go live Time :
Statement : deleting

Edit summary : deleting
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : Michael
Go live Time :
Statement : The Doctrine of the "resurrection of the dead" taught by Isaiah, Daniel, Ezekiel, Jesus and Mohammed is, in Truth, a monotheistic Doctrine of 'Rebirth' similar to the Buddhist Doctrine of 'Rebirth'. It is based upon the Revelation of the "resurrection"; which includes the Revelation of the Memory of Creation (Genesis 2:7) and the revelation of the memories of previous lives; as cryptically referred to in Isaiah 8:16 and 26:19, and Daniel 12:2; and figuratively described by Jesus in his reply to the Sadducees (Luke 20:1-40; especially vs. 34-36).

Edit summary : Revision of the Original
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : Michael
Go live Time :
Statement : The Doctrine of the "resurrection of the dead" taught by Isaiah, Daniel, Ezekiel, Jesus and Mohammed is based upon the Revelation of the "resurrection"; which includes the Revelation of the Memory of Creation (Genesis 2:7) and the revelation of the memories of previous lives; as cryptically referred to in Isaiah 8:16 and 26:19, and Daniel 12:2; and figuratively described by Jesus in his reply to the Sadducees (Luke 20:1-40; especially vs. 34-36).

Edit summary : First Version
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : Michael
Go live Time :