Topic: PhilPaprs Srvy Perception

Camp: Agreement / Sense-datum Theory

Camp Statement History

Not Live
Statement :

Sense-datum Theory

  • Lean toward: sense-datum theory: 259 / 3226 (6.6%)
  • Accept: sense-datum theory: 50 / 3226 (1.5%)
  • Total: 190 / 3226 (5.8%)

We are only aware of our representations of what our senses detect and there is a 'veil of perception' between our first hand knowledge and it's referent.
Tim Crane has some great ideas, and a brief survey of sense data in his "Origin's of Qualia" paper: ( G.E. More was the originator of the idea of sense-datum and it was popularized by Russell. Moor oscillated between the idea that "sense-data are mind-independent objects presented in experience" and that "sense-data are not mind-independent objects".
H.H. Price clarified by talking about things we cannot deny when we perceive a tomato such as its "there exists a red patch of a round and somewhat bulgy shape, standing out from a background of other colour-patches". He said that " This peculiar and ultimate manner of being present to consciousness is called being given, and that which is thus present is called a datum. Goguen points out that "Price thought it a 'gross absurdity' to suppose that the existence of sensedata depend on our awareness of them."
Howard Robinson endorsed this view with what he called the 'Phenomenal Principle': that 'when one has an sensory experience as of something being F, there is something F which one is experiencing.'

Edit summary : First Version
Submitted on :
Submitter Nick Name : Brent_Allsop
Go live Time :