Folks, I think there is a possibility that there might be a better, more accurate structure that appropriately represents all the best theories of consciousness held by everyone than currently exists in the [http://canonizer.com/topic.asp/23 Hard Problem topic]. But so far, I have not yet seen any information about or evidence for such. Can anyone think of any information that might hint at a better structure? If not, then I think we should just start duplicating that structure here. If I don't hear any compelling information about how to better structure this topic in the next few days, I'm going to start creating and integrating a parallel structure that represent my personal camp: Not Supernatural / Consciousness is Real / Phenomenal Properties And everyone else can do the same or similar for their camps. Of course, as more people get involved, and we have much more comprehensive points of view included, better ways to structure things may become clear. At such time we can always restructure things accordingly. For a review of what makes a good structure see this [http://canonizer.com/topic.asp/89/2 canonized camp on POV Structure]. Brent Allsop