Browsing as: Guest_39


Register New User


Canonizer algorithm:

Algorithm Information

Filter <

As Of

include review


as of (yy/mm/dd):



Canonizer Main

What Is


Create New Topic

Upload File

Topic Camp Tree

This section is a table of contents for this topic. It is in outline or tree form, with supporting sub camps indented from the parent camp. If you are in a sub camp, you are also counted in all parent camps including the agreement camp at the top. The numbers are canonized scores derived from the people in the camps based on your currently selected canonizer on the side bar. The camps are sorted according to these canonized scores. Each entry is a link to the camp page which can contain a statement of belief. The green line indicates the camp page you are currently on and the statement below is for that camp.

Canonizer Sorted Camp Tree
Camp Statement

Functional Property Dualism

This theory predicts that functionality is what ties phenomenal properties to physical matter in our brain.

In 1995, David Chalmers authored a paper entitled "Absent Qualia, Fading Qualia, Dancing Qualia" in which he proposes a principle of organizational invariance: "The invariance principle holds that any functional isomorph of a conscious system has experiences that are qualitatively identical to those of the original system" ( He makes his argument through a set of thought experiments involving replacing some or all neurons (he assumes neurons are the fundamental elements of the organization that is the brain but this is not a crucial assumption). He argues that the implausibility of fading or dancing qualia is reason enough to claim that qualia (the stuff of conscious experience) will somehow "arise" from whatever physical matter is abstractly behaving like the neurons, just as it does in the brain. He takes this to mean (contra Searle) that such diverse things as a set of water pipes or an entire population would be conscious if organized correctly. He states his conclusion thus:

"I conclude that by far the most plausible hypothesis is that replacement of neurons while preserving functional organization will preserve qualia, and that experience is wholly determined by functional organization."

Camp Support

Supporters can delegate their support to others. Direct supporters receive e-mail notifications of proposed camp changes, while delegated supporters dont. People delegating their support to others are shown below and indented from their delegates in an outline form. If a delegate changes camp, everyone delegating their support to them will change camps with them.

Support Tree for "Functional Prprty Dualism" Camp

Total Support for This Camp (including sub-camps): 5

Current Topic Record:

Topic Name: Theories of Consciousness

Name Space:

Current Camp Record:

Camp Name: Functional Prprty Dualism

Title: Functional Property Dualism

Key Words: functional, equivalence, property dualism

Related URL:

Related Nick Name:

Parent Camp: Mind-Brain Identity